Leibish & Co Review

The Company – Leibish and Co Review

Leibish & Co. is an internationally renowned specialist and online dealer of natural, colored diamonds and colored diamond jewelry. The brand is one of the largest online sellers of colored diamonds, offering a variety of both fancy and ideal cuts in various hues, clarities, and sizes set for any budget.

Very early on, Leibish recognized the huge potential of the internet as a worldwide sales, marketing, and service channel, and made sure that his brand was one of the very first fancy colour diamond companies to go online in 1995.

Today, the brand has earned its place as a leading supplier to renowned jewelers, designers, and manufacturers throughout the world, synonymous with excellence in the world of Fancy Color Diamonds. But, despite their global success, the company still retains its strong, family values.

The History

Leibish & Co was launched in 1979 by Leibish Polnauer, as a close-knit, family business. However, he hadn’t always dreamt of working within the diamond industry. In fact, the company came about quite by chance!

Polnauer had just been informed that the polishing factory he worked in had been shut down, when he happened to see an add from the Royal Crown Jeweller, Garrard & Co. They were looking for a specific, hard-to-find diamond, and Leibnish decided he would deliver. And sure enough, having scoured the globe, he found the diamond as well as some other ones that Garrard was looking for. And, as they say, the rest is history…

Leibish & Co Engagement Rings

Leibish & Co offers a range of settings for their diamonds, though their style leans heavily towards distinctive, bold designs that may not suit all tastes. If you’re looking for clean, simple elegance or designer options, you may find their selection somewhat limited. Their settings tend to feature intricate or unusual detailing, which can overshadow the diamond itself rather than letting its natural beauty shine.

For customers with a minimalist aesthetic or those seeking well-known designer settings, the lack of simpler, refined designs and absence of designer collaborations might be disappointing. While Leibish & Co does provide the option to create a custom ring, the selection of base settings may not offer the versatility or classic appeal some buyers are after.

Leibish & Co Diamonds

Leibish & Co exclusively sells natural diamonds, which may be limiting for customers open to lab-grown options. Their selection is fairly restricted, especially given the rarity of high-quality colored diamonds, making it challenging to find exceptional stones without significant browsing.

While they provide HD video and images for most diamonds, the absence of light performance videos is a notable drawback, as it makes it difficult to assess how each diamond will sparkle in real life. On the positive side, their diamonds come with GIA certification, ensuring a reliable standard of grading.

Overall, Leibish & Co’s diamond selection is limited, and finding standout options may require extra effort. However, for those willing to search, there are some interesting choices available.

Additional Benefits and Policies

Leibish & Co provides a few appealing benefits, including interest-free payment plans, which can help make larger purchases more manageable. They also offer free shipping and a 30-day return policy, though these are standard for most reputable jewelers. A money-back guarantee adds some reassurance, and their warranty covers manufacturing defects for added peace of mind. However, one key offering missing from their services is a trade-up program. For many diamond buyers, the option to upgrade in the future is a significant factor, and the absence of this benefit could be a drawback for those looking to enhance or replace their purchase down the line—even if it’s something they don’t expect to need right away.

The Bottom Line

Overall, my experience with Leibish & Co left much to be desired. The website felt frustratingly slow and cumbersome to navigate, which detracted from the shopping experience. While they offer a selection of natural colored diamonds, the limited stock and lack of lab-grown options make it difficult to find exactly what you’re looking for without considerable effort.